Historic Church Leans Closer to its Demise in Florida

Island Grove Methodist Church | Alachua County Fl | c. 1880s

Long forgotten and on its last legs stands* Island Grove Methodist Church.

Located in a modern-day ghost town, this 19th century (circa 1885) church opened its doors and provided religious service and ceremony for local farmers, fishermen and citrus growers until 1972.

Island Grove Church as it looked in the 1980s with the steeple still in tact. Photo courtesy of Debra Oliver.

Harsh winters, tough times and shifting industry forced most out of the area and further south, leaving this once-blossoming community to fall into historical obscurity. 


Structures like this one are few and far between but stand like tombstones marking the places where life used to happen.

The floor is sinking into the ground.

The back wall has become largely detached from the main structure. The interior ceiling is collapsing. Even the steeple is missing.

A building like this is a museum in its most real, unadulterated form. But the last 40 years of disuse certainly show. It will be a sad day when I visit this site and the church no longer stands. But for now, there is someone who cares about this place.

YOU CAN ALSO READ:   The Abandoned Hayes Family Farmhouse

In the early 2000s, a local stepped up to buy the property and agreed to do what he could to to save it. A new roof was put on which has likely been all that has kept it around the past 20 years.


As of 2017, the parcel of land where this church sits was separated from the larger tract where it used to be contained because the present owners were not able to properly insure their land while the church stood on their property.

The church parcel was sold and the new owners plan to take down this old church and reclaim any materials that are still usable.

Do You Enjoy These Stories? Help Support This Project So I Can Bring You More!

YOU CAN ALSO READ:   Old Georgia Farmhouse Down a Dirt Road

9 thoughts on “Historic Church Leans Closer to its Demise in Florida”

  1. Tis a fine and noble work youre doing. That ye hath the wherewithal to so do is wonderful. Please keep on keeping on.

  2. The post office in Island Grove is where Marjorie Kennan Rawlings received her mail. As you probably know, she was the author of “The Yearling,” “Cross Creek,” and, many other novels and other literary works. “Miz Rawlins” as she was called lived in a little “cracker house” in the village of Cross Creek a few miles to the west of Island Grove. She is interred at Antioch Cemetery a short distance northeast of Island Grove.

  3. In your research, have you learned that this historic church in Island Grove, FL was once named Simms AME Church?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top